Billing

billing

For your convenience, we have listed the contact information for the billing departments of some of our companies below; if your policy is through one of these companies, please contact them directly to make a payment or ask a question regarding your bill. Please note, you must have your policy number or account number available when calling.

We would like to help if you have billing or payment inquiries and your insurance company is not listed below. Please call our office at (440) 826-3880 with your questions.

Insurance CompanyBilling Phone NumberImportant Notes

Auto-Owners

1-800-346-0346
ext. 8740

Check by telephone only. $5.00 fee (Credit cards not accepted.)

Donegal

   

Grange

1-800-425-1100  

MetLife

1-800-680-3354

Check or credit card accepted.

Motorist Mutual

1-800-611-9928

Check or credit card accepted.

Online payments available at https://paymentsmotorists.billmatrix.com/

Ohio Casualty

1-800-543-1953

Credit cards only.

Progressive

1-887-776-2436

Credit cards. Online payment also available at http://www.personalprogressive.com

(Personal insurance only.) First time user required to register ID and password.

Safeco

1-800-332-3226

Credit cards only.

State Auto

1-800-444-9950
ext. 5118

Automated Phone Premium payments can be made any time of the day or night, seven days a week - follow the prompts.

Utica First

   

Westfield

1-800-766-9133

To make your payment, have your policy or account number and your access code available. Your access code is your zip code as it appears on your Westfield invoice. $3.95 fee

Insurance Products

  • Business Insurance +

    Whether you are a large company or a small business, we can help you save money and provide you with Read More
  • Personal Insurance +

    At Thornburg Insurance, you can count on us to protect what’s most valuable to you.  We represent many insurance companies Read More
  • Medical Insurance +

    Most of our business clients use us for their group plans. We are also a COSE Agency. Are you in Read More
  • Life Insurance +

    While coverage for your valuable assets is necessary and very important, what if something should happen to you? Owning adequate Read More
  • Hospitality Insurance +

    Thornburg Insurance Services is dedicated to providing a complete package program to the restaurant/tavern market niche.  Whether you need insurance Read More
  • 1
Ask a question